CAS upholds FIFA fines on Mexico over homophobic chant, overturns stadium closure

The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) on Tuesday upheld FIFA fines imposed on the Mexican Football Federation (FMF) over the use of a homophobic chant by supporters but overturned a partial stadium closure ordered in one of the disciplinary cases.

CAS said the FMF must pay ‌separate fines of 60,000 Swiss francs ($76,287) and 80,000 Swiss francs after appeals against FIFA sanctions stemming from incidents during four international friendlies in 2024.

FIFA's anti-discrimination monitoring system reported the chant during friendlies against Bolivia, Uruguay and Brazil in the summer of 2024, with two of those matches temporarily suspended.

FIFA's disciplinary committee subsequently fined the FMF 60,000 Swiss francs and ordered a 15% closure of ⁠the stadium for Mexico's next FIFA match.

A separate case stemming from an October 2024 friendly against the United States resulted in an additional fine of 80,000 Swiss francs.

The FMF appealed both decisions to CAS, arguing it had invested significant resources since 2015 in efforts to eliminate the chant and that the sanctions were ineffective in preventing further incidents.

Following a hearing in Miami in March, the CAS panel reviewed evidence including match footage and concluded that the conduct was "collective and widespread, and not merely a one-off occurrence".

"The panel recognises the unique nature of the FMF's situation, who demonstrated that significant financial resources and efforts ‌have been ⁠deployed to eradicate the offending conduct," CAS said.

"However, they found that the prohibited conduct persists, and the preventative measures do not carry sufficient legal weight to exempt the FMF from liability."

The panel concluded that the fines imposed by FIFA were "the correct sanction and proportionate to the disciplinary offence".

However, it partially upheld the appeal and annulled the ⁠15% stadium closure.

"The CAS panel considered that the FIFA Disciplinary Commission applied an unjustified double standard for proceedings with substantially identical facts," the ruling said.

The appeal relating to the October 2024 friendly against the United States was dismissed.

Mexico has ⁠repeatedly faced sanctions from FIFA and CONCACAF over the chant, which is typically directed at opposing goalkeepers during goal kicks.

Last month, the FMF launched a campaign urging supporters to stop the chant after FIFA ⁠ordered the partial closure of Puebla's Cuauhtemoc Stadium for a World Cup warm-up match against Ghana.

Mexico will co-host the World Cup alongside the United States and Canada, opening the tournament against South Africa on June 11.

Comments

Nigeria backs ANOCA rotation policy as Uganda lands 2031 African Games hosting rights

By Maxwell Kumoye Uganda's emergence as host of the 2031 African Games has been linked to the rotational hosting policy of the Association of National Olympic Committees of Africa (ANOCA), a framework designed to ensure equitable distribution of the continent's biggest multi-sport event among Africa's regions. Investigations have revealed that the East African nation benefited significantly from the policy, which seeks to spread hosting opportunities across the continent rather than concentrating them in a few countries. The decision is also understood to have been aided by Nigeria's withdrawal from the race, leaving Uganda as the sole candidate for the prestigious event. For Nigeria, supporting the rotational arrangement aligns with the country's longstanding contribution to the growth of the African Games movement. The nation has already hosted the continental showpiece twice, first in Lagos in 1973 and again in Abuja in 2003, making it one of only a handful of c...

Glazer family members studying Manchester United stake sale, Bloomberg News reports

Some Glazer family members have been debating whether ‌to sell their stake in Manchester United FC (MANU.N), opens new tab after more than two decades ⁠of ownership, Bloomberg News reported on Wednesday, citing people familiar with the matter. Several stakeholders in the Glazer family have been studying ‌the ⁠possibility of divesting part or all of their holdings in the English ⁠Premier League football club, according to the report. — Reuters

Protests and last-minute construction work disrupt Mexico City ahead of World Cup

Eight days before Mexico City kicks off the World Cup, mass protests by teachers and retired judges, road closures and last-minute construction work caused chaos in the capital on Wednesday for millions of residents who face long delays and complex rerouting of their daily commutes. On June 11, Mexico City will host the inaugural World Cup match between ‌Mexico and South Africa at Azteca stadium in the capital. With Mexico in the global spotlight, teachers and other groups have staged marches and blocked major avenues. They have said their protests, which are unrelated to the tournament, could intensify unless President Claudia Sheinbaum's government addresses their demands. The CNTE, a dissident wing of the national teachers' union, has threatened mass demonstrations at the opening of the World Cup in official statements shared on social media. The union is demanding the government fulfill a campaign pledge to repeal a 2007 law that overhauled the pension and ⁠social securit...

Iran to play World Cup warm-up behind closed doors, head to Mexico on Saturday

Iran will play their final World Cup warm-up behind closed doors in Turkey on Thursday before departing for their tournament base in Mexico on Saturday, the Iranian FA (FFIRI) said on Wednesday. Although it was one of the first teams to ‌qualify, Iran's participation in the World Cup has been in doubt since the U.S. and Israel launched air strikes on the Islamic Republic in late February. The squad have played three friendlies in two training camps in Antalya since the start of the war - losing to Nigeria and beating Costa Rica and Gambia - and on Thursday will face Mali ⁠in the Turkish sea resort. "Considering the importance of the Iranian national football team's friendly match against Mali, and in line with the tactical objectives of Iran's head coach, tomorrow's match against Mali will be held behind closed doors and without media attendance," FFIRI said in a statement. The FFIRI persuaded FIFA to allow the team to swap its tournament base from Tucson, A...

Z-PRO MEDIA

Search This Blog